I am always in convalescence after the aggression I was victim on september 6th. My body is now in good shape, but my moral is very low. I am not doing many things. But that’s not the subject of this post. These last days at home, my family decided to install a wifi network. Since I am _the_technician_ of the house - you probably know that, when someone meet a problem on his PC, he never forget to get in touch with you - my policy was to let only PC under Linux to connect to the Internet with the wifi. This occasion was a great opportunity to test ubuntu. In the past I had tested progeny, and I quickly come to Debian. Not because Progeny was bad, but because it was perhaps too early to have a stable distribution only working with a GUI. I was very surprised by Ubuntu, first because its look is very nice, but the most important is that ubuntu brings a lot of nice tools unavailable under Debian testing or unstable : Gnome 2.8 for ex. I was not a fanatic of gnome, but a few month ago I tried Gnome as soon as 2.6 entered into our distribution. Now I am still using gnome (I am using gnome-terminal a lot).
I read a lot of emails, posts and comments about ubuntu, but to be honnest ubuntu makes me wonder about the future of Debian. I am not sad, but to my mind we have to resolve our problems in a near future otherwise our project will loose its energy, its maintainers, and its users.
Strong projects from Debian have been included into Ubuntu, the others have “not yet been integrated” or have been ignored… I do not want to make here a judgment on debian maintainers but we have to see the reality in front. 3 examples to show the interest of Ubuntu:
The debian-installer has been included without major changes because it’s nice and because Joey Hess is doing a nice work (He is not alone, but he realised a very big work).
Some people from the gnome-team have been recruited by canonical (that’s a great opportunity for them, and I deeply belive that canonical did a good choice).
Ubuntu is providing an up-to-date distribution with security support and the most important packages (other packages, from universe are only included to provide a lot of packages to ubuntu users).
Let’s go back a few seconds on the gnome-team. (Note that I am not involved in maintaining gnome)
What interest for people involved in gnome-team, when they must upload the lastest stable release of gnome (2.8) only in experimental, and when gnome users are only repporting bugs that have been fixed in 2.8 ? If I remember correctly, a few month ago (before the summer) the gnome-team was obliged to convince the release team that gnome 2.6 was not breaking gnome 2.4 because we were about to release Sarge. Now, gnome 2.8 has been released, we still do not have released Sarge. Are gnome-maintainers supposed to wait for the release of Sarge before uploading 2.8 into unstable ? I understand that they are interested by Ubuntu. Nobody can blame those guys. Ubuntu is based on gnome 2.8 and I can tell you that It works well.
I really belive that some “key persons” on the Debian project should stop focusing on their own person, and should recognise the reality. Debian is not on the good way. I wish I had not such idea, but unfortunately currently I do not think that we are doing the right things (except debian-installer, gnome-team and translators). I am really tired to see people complaining that Ubuntu is not intersting. Sorry guys, but at least test it.
I am still using Debian on my PCs. But today I was obliged to grab packages from ubuntu to use gnome 2.8… My question is simple today I started to grab packages from Ubuntu, gnome was the first, what packages will follow on the list ? And I wonder if I will see Debian as motivating than in the past when I decided to join the project.
P.S. I do not know if my low motivation on Debian is a consequence of my agression, or if it’s related to Ubuntu and the indifference of some Debian maintainers that refuse to see that Debian is on a difficult path.